This blog is a labour of love, fueled by readers like you. As an affiliate, I earn commissions from qualifying purchases made through retail links in this post. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.
My experience here was okay. The character dynamics and the dual‑timeline structure were interesting at first, and the introduction of the mystery had me curious. I liked the sense of atmosphere, the Harlem setting, and the way the book blended romance with a touch of magical realism. I can see why that mix really works for some readers who might enjoy this more than I did.
But somewhere around the halfway point, I struggled to stay engaged. Several plot turns felt predictable to me early on. I was willing to overlook that at first, but I found myself enjoying the story less and less as it went on. The romance — and the way it was written here — just isn’t my style. It also took me off guard, perhaps because the cover reminded me of a different kind of story — something more in the Taylor Jenkins Reid lane — which shaped my expectations without me realizing it. Unfortunately, the romance wasn’t something I connected with at all. By the end, I was reading quickly just to see where it was going rather than because I cared about the journey or the characters.
This book had promise, but it didn’t quite land for me — though I’m sure it will find readers who connect with its tone and themes more than I did. It reminded me a bit of romantasy in its vibe, so if you enjoy those, this might be worth a try.
2.25 ⭐
—
Rating Guide: My star ratings represent personal resonance, not universal value. I admire writers for the courage it takes to be seen and the discipline it takes to create. Thank you for writing, and for reading.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 — Deeply resonant, even when I can’t fully put it into words
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4 — Compelling and well-written
⭐⭐⭐ 3 — Not quite my style, but still enjoyable
⭐⭐ 2 — Had promise but didn’t quite land
⭐ 1 — Fell short of what I hoped for
My descriptions are based on the original meanings of Goodreads' star ratings; see my Goodreads bio for details.
